Key Takeaways
- Health plans are weighing AI by what it does for member trust and experience, not just what it saves.
- AI succeeds when it starts with a business problem, and it is changing productivity expectations more than staffing models.
- Member services is becoming a balance of AI and human support, which makes workforce capability the deciding factor.
Our team spent two days in Chicago at the Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable, and AI came up in nearly every session. Between the panels and the hallway conversations, the discussion kept circling back to people: who handles the member conversations AI can’t, and how ready they are.
U.S. call centers lose 30% or more of their agents each year on average, according to ContactBabel. Deloitte Digital also found that three in four contact center leaders say agents are overwhelmed by the systems and information in front of them. When Annual Planning Cycles Outlive the Skills They’re Built Around
Top 5 Themes at the Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable
Becker’s Healthcare brought plan executives together on November 2 and 3 to talk about AI, Medicare Advantage, member trust, and cost pressures.
A survey presented at the event found plan executives ranked network accuracy, compliance, and member satisfaction ahead of cost reduction as AI drivers.
1. Member trust and experience are driving AI investment priorities.
Ask a health plan executive why they’re investing in AI, and the answer increasingly starts with the member. A Humana leader put the test simply: if a tool won’t benefit members or providers, the plan won’t build it. Its AI pulls data from four or five systems so call center reps can resolve complex benefit issues faster, and the plan says members now have more confidence in the answers they get.
Trust is rebuilt through transparency and plain talk, even when the news is bad, said panelists from Sidecar Health and the North Carolina State Health Plan. It gets tested in the difficult moments: a surprise bill, a denied claim, a provider leaving the network, a prior authorization that takes too long. One plan leader pointed out that providers often tell patients the insurer will get back to them, because plans haven’t given providers clear talking points. The plan then absorbs the frustration.
Key takeaways for ops leaders:
- Trust and experience are decided in conversations with members, which puts frontline teams at the center of the case for AI.
- Equip reps for the hard moments. That means practice on what to say when a bill surprises a member, a claim is denied, or a provider leaves the network, and how to explain a prior authorization delay without sending the member away unhappy.
- Give providers and members consistent talking points so the plan isn’t absorbing avoidable frustration.
2. AI success starts with business problems, not technology.
Plans that get value from AI name the problem first and pick the tool second. A Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas leader framed it as aspirin versus vitamin: with margins under pressure, his team only buys the tools that relieve a real pain point.
A research executive from KLAS Research described how the questions have changed. Plans used to ask which vendor to pick. Now they ask where to deploy AI, often before naming a problem, and the ones getting results start with the outcome and decide up front how they’ll measure it. A Presbyterian Healthcare Services executive added a warning: AI is an accelerator, and it can’t fix a flawed process. Another plan leader noted that critical process knowledge often sits with a few long-tenured employees, and that no tool can map a process the plan hasn’t defined.
Key takeaways for ops leaders:
- Define how work gets done before adding AI to it.
- Capture what long-tenured staff know. It’s often undocumented, and both new hires and AI tools depend on it.
- Look at where members get stuck. That’s where a tool is worth the investment.

3. AI is changing productivity expectations, not just staffing models.
An Amazon Web Services executive framed the goal as raising each employee’s output, and one plan executive said AI tools have improved the quality of work without cutting a single position, though that could change.
The worry hasn’t gone away. A leader at CareFirst Community Health Plan Maryland said concern about job displacement remains, so the plan handed out AI tools and asked staff to show what they built at monthly meetings, framing it as learning, not scrutiny. A Banner Plans and Networks leader described the challenge as moving staff from fear to seeing AI as an enabler. Another leader cautioned that asking people to do more through constant change leads to burnout.
Key takeaways for ops leaders:
- Higher productivity expectations only hold if staff have the time, skills, and practice to use the tools, so build capacity before raising targets.
- Give reps practice on realistic situations, not just a tool rollout and a training module. Reps handling more complex work with AI beside them need to rehearse the judgment calls.
4. Member services is becoming a balance of AI and human support.
AI agents for the call center came up as a big target, from speakers at KLAS Research and Amazon Web Services alike. Elevance Health described a member app with a built-in virtual assistant, with voice AI and appointment scheduling next, and is working on pairing digital outreach for members with chronic conditions with concierge human care.
Plans serving older members were quick to add limits. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont said it can’t roll out AI at the expense of phone service for its older population. A Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas leader said AI can speed answers, but the call should still end with a person. Medicare Advantage panelists added the practical barriers: portal rules that now require a cell phone, fraud aimed at seniors by phone, and members who still distrust mail-order pharmacy.
Key takeaways for ops leaders:
- Each channel needs its own kind of readiness: accurate content for self-service, governance and clean data for AI, and well-prepared people for the conversations that are left.
- Expect those conversations to be harder, to span more systems, and to involve members who are anxious or upset.
Plan a way to know your advocates are ready, not just trained.
5. Medicare Advantage member experience is changing under Stars.
Would you notice if your gym’s app dropped a few extras? Probably not. You’d notice a broken treadmill or a higher monthly fee. A Humana leader used that analogy to explain what matters to seniors, and it fits a wider shift. One panelist said the industry is calling this era the great Medicare Advantage reset, with plans returning to the benefits that matter most.
Star Ratings are moving the same way. One speaker said CMS is moving weight toward member experience and clinical outcomes and away from administrative measures. Another said a good rating can no longer be assumed, so plans need to be able to absorb a down year.
Key takeaways for ops leaders:
- Member experience is built on calls. During the Annual Enrollment Period, member advocates handle identity checks, benefit questions, and members anxious about changes.
- Consistency across member advocates matters as much as the best individual call.
- Those conversations shape the ratings plans are striving for.
What These Trends Mean for Health Plan Operations
Across the discussions at Becker’s, a common message emerged: health plans are looking to improve member trust, experience, and operational efficiency, with AI playing a growing role. But success depends on solving the right problems, improving productivity, and ensuring employees can adapt as their work evolves.
Here’s what the five themes mean for the workforce:
- Member trust and experience are often shaped by conversations with members.
- Solving business problems first depends on understanding existing processes and capturing what experienced staff know.
- Higher productivity expectations require time, skills, and practice with new tools.
- Balancing AI and human support means preparing advocates for more complex, high-trust conversations.
- Medicare Advantage Star Ratings put member experience under scrutiny, and frontline interactions play an important role.
Together, these takeaways highlight an important implication for health plan operations: technology investments alone aren’t enough. As AI changes how work gets done, health plans also need to invest in the people delivering the member experience.
We’ve seen the impact of investing in workforce capability firsthand. Through an applied learning program with Intrepid, UnitedHealthcare reduced time-to-proficiency for its Medicare Appeals & Grievances team from nine months to six weeks.
As health plans continue investing in AI and operational improvements, developing the people who deliver the member experience deserves just as much attention as the technology supporting them.
Sessions we attended
Organizations quoted above appear in these panels. Here’s who was on stage, by full agenda title.
- AI in Payer Operations: What’s Working Inside the Plans. Paula Shepherd (Banner Health Plans), Mike Rapach (CareFirst Community Health Plan Maryland), Raj Nair (Presbyterian Healthcare Services), Kathleen Leonard and Ruchir Ranjan (Simplify Healthcare)
- AI and Digital Transformation: The New Frontier in Health Plan Performance. Umair Lateef (Humana), Arnab Bose (UST), Jason Aldous (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Vermont), Dennis Depenbusch (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas)
- Winning Member Trust: New Playbooks for Engagement, Transparency, and Lasting Loyalty. Dennis Depenbusch (Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Kansas), Kevin Knight (Sidecar Health), Thomas Friedman (North Carolina State Health Plan)
- Driving Growth in Medicare Advantage: Opportunities and Challenges. Kortney Cruz (Independence Blue Cross), Vishal Kaushik (Humana), Jennifer Volm (Jefferson Health Plans), Roger van Baaren (Geisinger Health Plan), Karen Lewis Smith (PacificSource Health Plans)
- How Payers Are Managing Industry Volatility to Stay Agile. Crissy Turino (Cook County Health), Mark El-Tawil (Blue Cross Blue Shield of Arizona), Nishant Anand (Altais)
- Scale Without Headcount: The Agentic Economy for Payers. Brian Cardinell (Amazon Web Services), Boyd Stewart (KLAS Research), Jay Meyers (Rula Health), Alex Cameron (Hyland)
- Joy Kincaid, Vice President, Product Development and Innovation, Elevance Health. Keynote Interview
Frequently Asked Questions about the Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable
What is the Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable?
The Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable is a two-day event from Becker’s Healthcare for health plan executives, held November 2 and 3, 2026, at the Swissôtel Chicago. Sessions cover strategy, operations, and policy.
What were the top themes at the Fall Becker’s Payer Issues Roundtable?
Plan executives focused on how AI affects member trust, productivity, and member services. Five themes stood out:
- Member trust and experience are driving AI investment priorities
- AI success starts with business problems, not technology
- AI is changing productivity expectations, not just staffing models
- Member services is becoming a balance of AI and human support
- Medicare Advantage member experience is changing under Stars
How are health plans using AI in member services?
Health plans are adding AI to routine member service tasks, such as virtual assistants in member apps and tools that pull information across systems for call center staff. They are keeping people on complex, high-trust conversations and preserving phone service for older members.
Will AI replace member services representatives?
Health plan leaders describe AI as a productivity and capacity tool, not a replacement. AI takes on more routine questions, and people handle complex conversations. Some leaders still worry about job displacement and about competitors running leaner, so the debate isn’t settled.
What does it mean for a member services agent to be ready for the call?
A ready agent can handle a real member interaction accurately and confidently, not just complete training.




